How To Screen Tenants | RentBoard

Landlord Guide: Best Practice For Screening and Selecting Tenants

Blog Image #1

As a landlord, one of the most crucial aspects of managing your rental property is selecting the right tenants. Finding responsible and reliable individuals ensures a positive renting experience for both parties involved.

In this guide, we'll explore best practices for screening and selecting tenants to help you make informed decisions and maintain a harmonious landlord-tenant relationship.


Establish Clear Rental Criteria


Begin by establishing clear rental criteria that outline your expectations for potential tenants. This may include a minimum credit score, income requirements, rental history, and references. Clearly communicate these criteria to applicants to set transparent expectations from the start.



Use a Comprehensive Rental Application


Design a thorough rental application to gather essential information about prospective tenants. Include sections for personal details, rental history, employment information, and references. Encourage applicants to provide as much detail as possible to aid in your decision-making process.



Credit and Background Checks


Conducting credit and background checks is a standard practice for tenant screening. Evaluate an applicant's credit history to gauge their financial responsibility and reliability. Additionally, a background check helps identify any criminal history that may pose a risk to your property or other tenants.


Verify Income and Employment


Ensure that potential tenants have a stable source of income to meet rent obligations. Request proof of employment, such as pay stubs or employment verification letters. This step helps you confirm their ability to pay rent consistently.



Contact Previous Landlords


Reach out to previous landlords to gather insights into an applicant's rental history. Inquire about their payment history, adherence to lease agreements, and any issues they may have encountered. This information provides valuable context for evaluating a tenant's suitability for your property.


Interview Prospective Tenants


Schedule an in-person or virtual interview with potential tenants to assess their communication skills and demeanour. Use this opportunity to discuss your expectations, answer any questions they may have, and gauge their overall suitability for your rental property.


Understand Fair Housing Laws


Familiarize yourself with fair housing laws to ensure that your tenant selection process complies with legal requirements. Avoid discrimination based on race, colour, religion, sex, national origin, disability, or familial status.


Require a Security Deposit


Implement a reasonable security deposit policy to protect your property from potential damages. Clearly outline the terms and conditions for the return of the deposit in the lease agreement, and comply with local regulations regarding security deposits.


Regularly Review and Update Policies


Periodically review and update your tenant screening policies to adapt to changing legal requirements and industry best practices. Staying informed ensures that you maintain an effective and fair screening process over time.



By implementing these best practices, you can enhance your ability to select reliable and responsible tenants for your rental property. Thorough tenant screening not only protects your investment but also contributes to a positive and respectful landlord-tenant relationship. 

Stay proactive, communicate clearly, and uphold fair practices to create a rental experience that benefits both parties involved.